Savoring Demarest, NJ: The Best Restaurants to Try in This Charming Bergen County Town

When travelers think of New Jersey dining destinations, bustling cities like Hoboken or Montclair often come to mind. But tucked away in Bergen County lies Demarest, NJ—a small town with a big appetite. Though modest in size, Demarest offers a diverse culinary landscape where cozy eateries, family-owned delis, and hidden gems serve up flavors that delight both locals and visitors. Whether you’re craving classic New Jersey pizza, hearty deli sandwiches, or a fine dining experience just minutes away, Demarest’s dining scene is proof that great meals are often found in unexpected places.

A Taste of Small-Town Flavor

Demarest’s restaurants reflect the borough’s character: welcoming, unpretentious, and deeply rooted in community. Many of the dining establishments here are family-run, passing recipes down through generations and treating customers like old friends. It’s the kind of place where the pizza maker knows your favorite topping, the barista remembers your coffee order, and the deli clerk piles your sandwich just the way you like it.

Top Restaurants and Eateries in Demarest

DiMola’s Pizzeria

A true staple of Demarest dining, DiMola’s Pizzeria has been serving up some of the best pies in Bergen County for years. Known for its thin, crispy crust and generous toppings, this local favorite is the go-to spot for families on a Friday night or students grabbing a quick bite after school. Beyond pizza, their pasta dishes and garlic knots are equally satisfying, making it a must-visit for anyone who appreciates authentic Italian-American comfort food.

Signature Dish to Try: The classic Margherita pizza with fresh basil and mozzarella—a simple, timeless favorite.

Madison Deli

No visit to Demarest is complete without a stop at Madison Deli, a beloved neighborhood institution. Here, sandwiches are stacked high with premium meats and cheeses, complemented by fresh bread baked daily. The deli has a loyal following thanks to its hearty portions and welcoming staff. It’s the perfect place for a casual lunch, whether you’re craving a pastrami on rye, a turkey club, or a classic New Jersey Taylor ham, egg, and cheese.

Signature Dish to Try: The Italian sub—packed with layers of ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato, and a drizzle of oil and vinegar.

Closter Plaza Dining (Nearby)

While technically in neighboring Closter, just minutes from Demarest New Jersey, the restaurants in Closter Plaza are local favorites for those looking to expand their options. From sushi and Korean barbecue to modern American cuisine, the plaza offers something for every craving. It’s a popular evening destination for Demarest locals, combining convenience with variety.

Signature Experience: Trying a mix of international flavors in one stop, from Japanese rolls to sizzling Korean bulgogi.

Neighborhood Cafés

Demarest is dotted with charming cafés where locals gather for morning coffee or afternoon pastries. These smaller establishments often fly under the radar but offer excellent lattes, freshly baked croissants, and cozy seating perfect for catching up with a friend or simply enjoying a quiet moment.

Signature Experience: Pair a cappuccino with a buttery almond croissant for a relaxing start to your day.

What Locals Love Most: The Food Traditions of Demarest

Food in Demarest isn’t just about what’s served—it’s about how it’s shared. Locals cherish the town’s culinary traditions, from pizza nights at DiMola’s to deli lunches at Madison. Seasonal festivals, like Demarest Day, also highlight community-centered dining, with food trucks and vendors dishing out everything from funnel cakes to barbecue.

And because Demarest is just a short drive from towns like Englewood, Tenafly, and Closter, many residents enjoy easy access to upscale dining and diverse cuisines. Still, there’s something special about the comfort food right at home—it’s affordable, familiar, and made with care.

Beyond Demarest: Nearby Dining Adventures

For those willing to venture a little farther, Bergen County’s food scene opens up even more. Within a 15-minute drive, visitors can discover:

• Englewood’s Bergen Performing Arts District – perfect for dinner and a show, with fine dining spots ranging from farm-to-table American to Mediterranean cuisine.
• Tenafly’s Main Street – lined with sushi bars, French cafés, and bistros that cater to more adventurous palates.
• Paramus – home to large-scale dining options, from steakhouses to trendy chains.

Demarest may be small, but its location ensures that world-class dining is always within reach.

Practical Tips for Dining in Demarest

Best Time to Visit Restaurants: Evenings and weekends are busiest at popular spots like DiMola’s, so arrive early to avoid long waits.

Reservations: Most restaurants in Demarest are casual and don’t require reservations, but nearby fine dining establishments often do.

Family-Friendly Dining: Almost all local eateries welcome families, offering kids’ menus and casual atmospheres.

Local Etiquette: Expect friendly service and a community vibe. Many places are cash-friendly, so carrying some on hand is a good idea.

Why Foodies Shouldn’t Overlook Demarest

At first glance, Demarest NJ may seem like a quiet, residential town without the bustling restaurant scene of larger cities. But therein lies its charm. Dining here is less about trendy fads and more about authentic flavors, family recipes, and the comfort of a community that takes pride in its food. Whether you’re indulging in a cheesy slice of pizza, biting into a towering deli sandwich, or enjoying coffee in a cozy café, you’ll find that every bite comes with a side of warmth and hospitality.

Demarest proves that the best dining experiences aren’t always found in flashy locations—they’re often in the small towns where food is made with love, shared with neighbors, and remembered long after the last bite.

Final Bite: The Culinary Heart of Demarest

Demarest, NJ, may not make the headlines for its restaurant scene, but it has all the ingredients for a memorable culinary journey. Its best restaurants—whether it’s the iconic DiMola’s Pizzeria, the beloved Madison Deli, or the inviting cafés scattered across town—capture the true spirit of small-town dining. Add to that the borough’s proximity to nearby dining hotspots, and you’ve got a destination that satisfies both simple cravings and gourmet adventures.

So the next time you’re exploring Bergen County, make a detour into Demarest. Pull up a chair, order a local favorite, and discover how this little town serves up some of New Jersey’s most comforting flavors.

Click here to read about Exploring Nature’s Charm: The Best Parks in Demarest, NJ.